Archive for April, 2009

On lights…

Tuesday, April 7th, 2009

Probably the most important thing you can add to your weapon, a light will help you locate, identify and engage a threat.  Most gun owners and even shooters will not practice shooting or even dry fire with a light.  The hard part of shooting with a light is working the switches and exercising light discipline, the mistake I see most often is people who don’t train enough will try to use their light to illuminate everything to recreate their comfort zone rather than being comfortable with the darkness and using lights sparingly to identify something specific.

Surefire light in 1 inch ring attached to FSB using Midwest Industries FSB rail, tape switch is secured by an elastic retainer band

Surefire light in 1 inch ring attached to FSB using Midwest Industries FSB rail, tape switch is secured by an elastic retainer band at 12 o'clock which allows ambidexterous light activation

For most long guns a light is easy to work as you will most likely have both hands on the weapon anyway, place the light far enough out to clear any obstructions, e.g. the front sight assembly, while keeping the switch close enough in to comfortably use the weapon.

For handguns it gets trickier since most will shoot better with both hands on the pistol than with just one, there are a variety of handgun/flashlight techniques which is beyond the scope of this blog post.  The best option is to have a weapon mounted flashlight, it may not be necessary on every pistol but at least on any that you plan on using to protect yourself and loved ones.

Which light?  Surefire is the standard, all others are striving to keep up.  Nobody ever bought a competitor because it was more expensive, the fact is that if prices were equal- Surefire wins.  Unbeatable warranty and proven track record make it an obvious, albeit expensive, choice.  I have used Inova and Blackhawk lights in the past as well as duct taping a 2 D cell Maglite to the handguards of my M16 back when I was in the army but the majority of the lights I own today are Surefire.

My preference is for push button switches over pressure pads as it is less cluttered, provides more positive engagement and is less likely to have a white light Negligent Discharge (ND) if bumped.

Photobucket

Larue Dual Light mount holding Blackhawk Falcata light and Laser Devices visible laser

If mounted on a carbine, the light should be accessible without changing your support side grip if not using the light and accessible by your other hand if you need to switch shoulders, meaning your firing side hand is now your support side hand.  This is an instance where a pressure pad, mounted to the 12 o’clock position behind the front sight base of an AR has the advantage as you can easily use either thumb to activate the light.  The advantage of the push button, particularly the click-on variants, is that you can turn the light on and leave it on before switching shoulders.

How much light?  While much is made of 6v or 9v and how many lumens a light has it still comes down to individual situations.  You need as much light as necessary to illuminate the longest area in your house or the immediate area outside your house.  From a tactical standpoint every time you activate your light you may be giving away your position to a potentially hostile adversary, therefore you need to be able to see as much as possible with each illumination.

Dual light with FS

VTAC light mounts holding Surefire G2's, redundant lighting as well as allowing light activation from either side

For example, if you hear something at the end of your driveway in the middle of the night and decide to investigate, the farther away you are the better.  Especially if you have the range advantage of a carbine or shotgun.  The only downside to “too much light” is the potential to blind yourself if illuminating things like mirrors or light colored walls in your home.

I also prefer incandescent to LED lights as my experience in the past has been that LED’s lack the “throw” to light up things, particularly if you’re in a well lit area trying to illuminate a poorly lit area.  Downside to incandescent bulbs is they burn out quicker and may be less durable to shock and recoil.

Home Defense Weapon Selection

Saturday, April 4th, 2009

“What should I get?”- I am asked this a lot, conventional wisdom is to get a shotgun or pistol.  Both have positive attributes but my personal preference is for a carbine, either an M4-type AR or a pistol caliber carbine like the Beretta Storm.

Shotgun:

Pros: Relatively inexpensive, politically correct and excellent ballistics

Cons: Generally requires 2 handed manipulation, heavy recoil and requires more training for high percentage/hostage rescue shots.

Handgun:

Pros: Portable, less expensive overall if also used as a concealed carry weapon, easier to shoot one handed and also politically correct depending on where you live.

Cons: Requires much more maintenance training than other platforms to make consistently accurate shots,  inherently limited ballistics

Pistol caliber carbine:

Pros: lower recoil than a shotgun, longer effective range than a pistol and generally usable by almost anyone.  Smaller and less expensive than most AR’s it can still be accessorized in the same way with lights and RDS’.  Depending on the model it can also use the same high capacity magazines as a pistol.  Best for those who want something at home but are not going to spend a lot of time doing maintenance training.

Cons: Less range than an AR and the pistol caliber is still ballistically inferior to either a shotgun or rifle round.

Redi-Mag for onboard ammunition storage, fixed BUIS, 4 MOA Aimpoint, white light, Wilderness 1 pt. sling, Tango Down VFG and Entry size stock with KAC 1" QD spacer

Redi-Mag for onboard ammunition storage, fixed BUIS, 4 MOA RDS, white light, Wilderness 1 pt. sling, Tango Down VFG and Entry size stock with KAC QD swivel

My reasons for an AR is that I’ve been handling an AR of one form or another since I joined the army at 17.  The AR is ergonomic and lends itself well to adding accessories which makes it easier to shoot such as a Red Dot Sight (RDS) like the Aimpoint series.  Any weapon that can potentially be used to defend oneself should have a white light for target identification and the AR, more than any other platform, has numerous options.

Compared to a shotgun; less recoil, higher capacity magazine in case you have to engage multiple targets, higher accuracy potential due to nature of ammunition, greater effective range if and easier to manipulate one handed should you be injured.

Compared to a pistol; same advantages of accuracy, range and magazine capacity with the only downside being that the pistol is easier to manipulate one handed.

The downsides are that none of this comes cheap, flashlights that cost $100 or more, sights that run in to the $100′s and now even quality ammunition is expensive when its available.  The counter-argument to that is that it only needs to pay for itself once if you have to use it in defense of your life or others.  It is also less politically correct than all the other options.

Many who buy AR’s will obsess about “lightweight” or “simple”, which takes away from many of the advantages of the AR.  If selected for home defense, it will most likely be used as the barricade the user in a safe room while waiting for the police, taken along to investigate the proverbial “bump in the night” or in an extreme circumstance, to actively close with and engage a threat.

Same concept as above but with an interchangeable 1 or 2 pt. CQD sling and Vltor collapsible stock

Same concept as above but with an interchangeable 1 or 2 pt. CQD sling and Vltor collapsible stock

As noted before, any weapon used for the defense of one’s life should have a white light and not just for the obvious reason of deployment at night.  You could potentially need a light if searching during the day if you have to look in to closets, vehicles or other parts that may not have natural or artificial light.  That could be what allows you to see some burglar hiding in a corner that you might’ve otherwise missed.

An RDS such as the Aimpoint or Eotech is also a huge advantage even when shooting at close ranges as it allows your eyes to stay focused on the target while still maintaining situational awareness.  The other principal advantage is that you no longer need a perfect cheekweld or shoulder position to accurately place rounds on the bad guy.  If shooting under furniture or around corners you can still take it off your shoulder to minimize the exposed portions of your body while sending rounds downrange by just placing the dot on the target.

What’s the ideal weight for a Home Defense (HD) AR? As lightweight as you can make it without sacrificing usability and as heavy as you can shoot it one handed

How much should you spend?  As much as you can afford and still be able to pay for quality training to use it.